- Gardner Fox ?
- Dick Ayers (signed)
- Ernie Bache
- Dick Ayers
- Ghost Rider [Rex Fury]; Longhair John (death); Rex Fury; Spectre; Sing Song; Mr. Brady; Mrs. Kinsler
- A killer named Longhair John terrorizes the western frontier until the Ghost Rider catches him and he is hanged. Unfortunately, it appears that he has returned as a ghost when a person looking like him continues to terrorize the area. The Ghost Rider decides to prove he is just a man and not the ghost that people think he is.
Bache inks per Nick Caputo, May 2014. Previous indexer credited Dick Ayers.
Name is changed from Ghost Rider to Haunted Horseman in the reprint and it is printed in black and white.