in Superman in the Fifties (DC, 2002 series) #[nn] ([September] 2002)
in Superman Annual (Atlas Publishing, 1951 series) #1961-1962 (1961) [black and white]
in Superman Annual (DC, 1960 series) #7 (Summer 1963)
in The Best of DC (DC, 1979 series) #25 (June 1982)Writer id by Bob Hughes. Art credit verfied by Bob Bailey and Gene Reed. (2011-04-05)
in Legion of Super-Heroes (DC, 1973 series) #1 (February 1973)Reprint info (Arthur Lortie).