- Script
- Al Feldstein ?
- Pencils
- Al Feldstein (illustrations); Johnny Craig (signed)
- Inks
- Al Feldstein (illustrations); Johnny Craig (signed)
- Letters
- ?; typeset
- Genre
- horror-suspense
Promotional ad showing the cover of The Crypt of Terror (1950 series) #17, with three Feldstein illustrations, on sale now. Appears on inside front cover.
- Script
- Johnny Craig (signed)
- Pencils
- Johnny Craig (signed)
- Inks
- Johnny Craig (signed)
- Colors
- ? (see notes)
- Letters
- Jim Wroten
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- Ah, we meet again, dear reader!
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- The Vault Keeper (host); Robert [aka Jules Vendette] (artist, death); unnamed art buyer; Lord James Cherringwood; Henry (villain, Robert's friend, death)
- Synopsis
- Henry was jealous of his artist friend Robert for not selling his etchings. One day Henry began selling Robert's work to an art buyer. Robert found out and confronted Henry, who threw acid in his face then dumped the body into an acid vat. Henry almost used up the wealth of Robert's drawings until he met a wax statue maker and opened a museum with him. When one of the statues' arms was damaged Henry found a human hand beneath it. Henry confronted the sculptor, who removed a wax mask from his face, revealing himself as Robert.
- Reprints
- Keywords
- Paris; Star-Bugle-Clarion
Colors were previously attributed to Marie Severin (see Indexer Notes for this issue’s cover, above).
This story features Craig's first depiction of the Vault-Keeper.
Inspired by the story "The Mystery of the Wax Museum" by Michael Curtiz.
Cover story.
- Script
- Gardner Fox; Harry Harrison ?
- Pencils
- Harry Harrison (signed as Harrison)
- Inks
- Wally Wood (signed as Wood)
- Colors
- ? (see notes)
- Letters
- Jim Wroten
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- My name is Walter Mallory.
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Pobb's (a butler); Tom Faversham (death); Walter Mallory; Sir Gregory Mallory (villain, a werewolf); Edmund Mallory (villain, a werewolf, flashback); Dennis Mallory (villain, a werewolf, Baron of Munscrief, flashback); Arthur Mallory (villain, a werewolf, flashback)
- Synopsis
- Walter Mallory believes that he is a werewolf, committing murder after murder, and is convinced when he uncovers the Mallory family's werewolf legend. He tells Scotland Yard about this and they agree to help capture the creature, but Walter is determined to end the string of killings, and is about to shoot himself when Scotland Yard enters and tells him that it was actually Sir Gregory (an accomplished hypnotist) who killed the people because they were blackmailing him. He had hypnotized Walter and put werewolf makeup on him to make Walter think he had committed the crimes... as a werewolf!
- Reprints
- Keywords
- monsters; Moors of Devon; Scotland Yard
"Came the Dawn" forward by Bill Mason credits Fox as the writer, so Fox is added and Harrison is given a ?. Letterer credit by Craig Delich.
Colors were previously attributed to Marie Severin (see Indexer Notes for this issue’s cover, above).
- Script
- Ivan Klapper ?
- Pencils
- Harvey Kurtzman
- Inks
- Harvey Kurtzman
- Colors
- Harvey Kurtzman ? (see notes)
- Letters
- Jim Wroten
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- Never had Tom Hawkins known such fear before...
- Genre
- detective-mystery; horror-suspense
- Characters
- Tom Hawkins; Jim; John Smith (in flashback, death); Emily Smith (John's wife, in flashback, death)
- Synopsis
- At the Hawkin's Tourist Colony, Tom is hitting the bottle as his friend Jim walks in, and explains that he is doing so because of a terrible dream he had the night before. In it, a couple come in to take a room for the night....but the woman fears that death is stalking her and kills a cat, believing it was death coming for her. The couple get into a fight he kills her, then shoots himself! Jim tells Tom it was just a nightmare and leaves. A few moments later, a car pulls up and the same couple Tom had seen in his dream were standing before him wanting a room!
- Reprints
- Keywords
- Hawkins Tourist Cabins
Script credit from Tales of Terror: The EC Companion. Previous indexer had Al Feldstein ?
Although drawn after Kurtzman drew "House of Horror" in The Haunt of Fear #15 (#1) (1950), the story in this issue was Kurtzman's first EC story to appear in print.
Marie Severin’s statement that “[Harvey] Kurtzman colored his own art, especially on covers...” (1995) suggests that Kurtzman colored stories that he drew, albeit perhaps less consistently than he colored his cover art.
_________
References:
Cassell, Dewey, with Aaron Sultan. 2012. “The Artists of EC Comics” (reprinting Severin 1995). In Marie Severin: The Mirthful Mistress of Comics. 46–47. Raleigh: TwoMorrows Publishing.
Severin, Marie (John Province, transcriber [uncredited]). 1995. “Mostly About Color.” In CFA-APA 36, January.