- Script
- Johnny Craig (signed as )
- Pencils
- Johnny Craig (signed as )
- Inks
- Johnny Craig (signed as )
- Colors
- Marie Severin
- Letters
- Jim Wroten
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- Ho, ho, ho! And what would you like for Christmas?
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- The Vault-Keeper (host); Santa Claus
- Synopsis
- A terrific thud w/the fireplace poker and her husband Joseph lay dead on the floor. But then she heard her little girl upstairs, who asked her mommy if Santa Claus had come yet, and was told no and to go back to sleep. The wife then returned downstairs, cleaned off the poker, turned on the radio and heard an announcement of a maniac woman-killer dressed as Santa on the loose in the area. She wondered how she would be able to get rid of Joseph's body, when there was a knock at the door. She looked outside and saw a Santa at her door, the woman-killer, and paniced knowing she couldn't call the Police w/her husband's body there on the floor. Quickly she ran to every door and window, locking them, putting Joseph into a closet and then trying to board up windows from the inside. Going upstairs to check on Carol, her daughter, the woman was terrified when she found the little girl gone.....but more terrified when she went downstairs to see Carol having let in "Santa Claus"!
- Reprints
- in Tales from the Crypt (Ballantine Books, 1964 series) (December 1964)
- in The Vault of Horror (Russ Cochran, 1982 series) #5 (1982)
- in Iskalde Grøss (Semic, 1982 series) #1 uke 46 [1987] (uke 46 1987)
which is reprinted- in Vault of Horror (Russ Cochran, 1991 series) #4 (March 1992)
- in Skræk (Semic Interpresse, 1994 series) #4 (4. august 1994)
- in Vault of Horror (Gemstone, 1994 series) #24 (July 1998)
- in The EC Archives: The Vault of Horror (Dark Horse, 2014 series) #4
- in Choke Gasp! The Best of 75 Years of EC Comics (Dark Horse, 2019 series) (2019)
- in The Fantagraphics EC Artists' Library (Fantagraphics, 2012 series) #33 - Deadly Beloved and Other Stories (January 2023) [Reprinted in black and white.]
- in The EC Archives: The Vault of Horror (Dark Horse, 2021 series) #4
Cover story, although the art doesn't quite match up. The murderer is not the victim's husband, was dressed as Santa Claus, and there was no coffin under the Christmas tree.
- Script
- Johnny Craig
- Pencils
- Graham Ingels
- Inks
- Graham Ingels
- Colors
- Marie Severin
- Letters
- Jim Wroten
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- Hee, hee! Well it's time for me to brew my goo...
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- The Old Witch (host); Billy (young blind boy, death); Billy's mother (death); Billy's father (death); Jed (Billy's step-father, death)
- Synopsis
- The little boy celebrated the best Christmas he ever had because he could now see! Born blind, all he ever knew was the love of his mother, and the companionship of his teddy bear. His father died, so Mom remarried a cruel and vicious man who mistreated her. He always said that the little boy had "shoe-button" eyes, just like his teddy. One day, the little boy's mother became deathly ill, and he asked his step-dad to help her. He abused her, took the boy's bear and ripped the eyes off of it. Mom sewed on new button eyes before she died. Jed killed the boy, who regained his sight in heaven.
- Reprints
- in EC Horror Library of the 1950's (Nostalgia Press, 1970 series) (1970)
which is reprinted- in Nacht der vampiers (Classics/Williams, 1973 series) (1973)
- in Den store skrækbog (Williams, 1974 series) ([1974])
- in Horreur - une anthologie en bandes dessinées (Williams France, 1974 series) (2e trimestre 1974)
- in EC Portfolio (Russ Cochran, 1971 series) #6 (1977)
- in The Vault of Horror (Russ Cochran, 1982 series) #5 (1982)
- in Iskalde Grøss (Semic, 1982 series) #6 [1988] (uke 35 1988)
- in Vault of Horror (Russ Cochran, 1991 series) #4 (March 1992)
- in Skræk (Semic Interpresse, 1994 series) #4 (4. august 1994)
- in Vault of Horror (Gemstone, 1994 series) #24 (July 1998)
- in The EC Archives: The Vault of Horror (Dark Horse, 2014 series) #4
- in The Fantagraphics EC Artists' Library (Fantagraphics, 2012 series) #29 - Accidents and Old Lace and Other Stories (January 2021) [Reprinted in black and white.]
- in The EC Archives: The Vault of Horror (Dark Horse, 2021 series) #4
Most of the story is told in flashback.