No real villain; story is a dream of Dusty's. Original indexer had "Gil Kane?" as penciller. Irv Novick credit from Gary Watson, August 2009.
Inking is similar to the signed Black Hood story by Shumaker in #49 with pen name PEN. Pencils look very much like that story too...
All the round faces with long nose look certainly like Vigoda. He is credited on this feature by Jerry Bails' Who's Who.
Originally credited "Gil Kane?". PEN is the pen name of Shumaker, but Kane shared the pen name PEN STAR with Shumaker.