- Script:
- Roy Thomas
- Letters:
- typeset
- Reprints:
Introduction to the series and notes on the first issue. On the inside front and inside back covers.
- Script:
- Roy Thomas; Dann Thomas (co-plotter)
- Pencils:
- Rafael Kayanan; Rich Buckler (pp. 1, 4, 6-7); Jerry Ordway (p. 12)
- Inks:
- Alfred Alcala; Bill Collins
- Colors:
- Adrienne Roy
- Letters:
- David Cody Weiss
- Genre:
- superhero
- Characters:
- Justice Society of America [Wonder Woman [Diana Prince Trevor]; Spectre [Jim Corrigan]; Hawkman [Carter Hall]; Dr. Mid-Nite [Charles McNider]; The Atom [Al Pratt]; Green Lantern [Alan Scott]; Flash [Jay Garrick]; Starman [Ted Knight]; Dr. Fate [Nabu; Kent Nelson]; Sandman [Wesley Dodds]; Superman [Kal-L; Clark Kent]; Johnny Thunder; Hourman [Rex Tyler]; Wildcat [Ted Grant]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Batman [Bruce Wayne] (of Earth-2); Thunderbolt; Black Canary [Dinah Drake]; Star-Spangled Kid; Power Girl; Huntress [Helena Wayne]]; Freedom Fighters [Black Condor]; Uncle Sam; Phantom Lady [Sandra Knight]; Plastic Man]; Harlequin [Molly Mayne]; Johnny Quick; Adolf Hitler; Valkyries; The King Bee; The Monster; The Psycho Pirate [Charles Halstead]; The Wizard; The Injustice Society of the World [The Gambler; The Brain Wave; Vandal Savage; Per Degaton; The Thinker; The Sportsmaster; Icicle; The Fiddler; The Huntress [Paula Brooks]]; Professor Damon Everson; Professor Malachi Zee; Dr. Wilfred Doome (unidentified); Dr. James Swanley (unidentified); Dr. Carter Nichols; James; Mr. Smythe; Franklin Roosevelt; Harry Hopkins; Professor Elwood P. Napier; Senator O'Fallon; Bill Jensen; Jimmy Olsen; Elvis Presley (cameo); Dwight Eisenhower (cameo); James Dean (cameo)
- Synopsis:
- Superman tells the gathered JSA how Batman's old associate Dr. Nichols gave him Batman's diary and other evidence that accuses the Justice Society of secretly fighting for the Nazi cause from the group's formation in November 1940 through the end of the war, and of covering it up since then. But their meeting is interrupted when the JSA members are taken into custody, pending a congressional investigation.
Rich Morrissey credited as "consultant."
Prof. Nichols frequently sent Batman and Robin through time via hypnosis several times from 1944 through 1963. This part briefly covers the JSA's entire history from their origin in DC Special (DC, 1975 series) #29 through Batman's death, though in the slanted way it is presented in Batman's diary.
- Script:
- ?
- Pencils:
- Everett Hibbard (original); Al Dellinges (recreation)
- Inks:
- Everett Hibbard (original); Al Dellinges (recreation)
- Colors:
- ?
- Letters:
- ?
- Genre:
- superhero
- Reprints:
- Reprint Note before Migration:
- from All-Star Comics (DC, 1940 series) #4 (March-April 1941) [see notes]
Original cover "recreated" by Al Dellinges per the text article.