- Script:
- Archie Goodwin
- Pencils:
- Reed Crandall
- Inks:
- Reed Crandall
- Letters:
- Ben Oda
- Genre:
- horror-suspense
- Reprints: show reprint note before migration
First page is printed on the inside front cover.
- Script:
- E. Nelson Bridwell
- Pencils:
- Angelo Torres
- Inks:
- Angelo Torres
- Letters:
- Ben Oda
- Genre:
- horror-suspense
- Reprints: show reprint note before migration
This one page was cut from #2's reprint of the story "One for De-Money".
- Script:
- Archie Goodwin
- Pencils:
- Angelo Torres (signed)
- Inks:
- Angelo Torres (signed)
- Letters:
- Ben Oda
- Genre:
- horror-suspense
- Reprints: show reprint note before migration
- Script:
- Archie Goodwin
- Pencils:
- Angelo Torres (signed)
- Inks:
- Angelo Torres (signed)
- Letters:
- Ben Oda
- Editing:
- Russ Jones (Original Editor)
- Genre:
- horror-suspense
- Characters:
- Herr Burgermeister
- Synopsis:
- Vampires are hunted by another creature of the night...
- Reprints: show reprint note before migration
- Script:
- Archie Goodwin
- Pencils:
- Gray Morrow (signed)
- Inks:
- Gray Morrow (signed)
- Letters:
- Ben Oda
- Genre:
- science fiction
- Reprints: show reprint note before migration
- Script:
- Archie Goodwin
- Pencils:
- Gray Morrow
- Inks:
- Gray Morrow
- Letters:
- Ben Oda
- Editing:
- Archie Goodwin (Original Editor)
- Genre:
- horror-suspense
- Characters:
- Sturgis; Cthylla; Shoggath
- Synopsis:
- When a whaling ship finds a man named Sturgis floating on the sea he tells them an incredible story of an island where Shoggath lives and the tragedy that happened there. Unfortunately, the story of Shoggath did not end when he escaped from the island.
- Reprints: show reprint note before migration
- Script:
- Archie Goodwin
- Pencils:
- Reed Crandall (signed)
- Inks:
- Reed Crandall (signed)
- Letters:
- Ben Oda
- Editing:
- Russ Jones (Original Editor); Archie Goodwin (Original Story Editor)
- Genre:
- horror-suspense
- Characters:
- Todd
- Synopsis:
- A hunter in New Mexico comes across a girl being held captive by group of men claiming that her family is cursed and she must be killed. He rescues her but then begins to suspect that they were right.
- Reprints: show reprint note before migration
Lettering credit from the index to the original Creepy presentation.
- Script:
- Archie Goodwin
- Pencils:
- Alex Toth (signed)
- Inks:
- Alex Toth (signed)
- Letters:
- Alex Toth
- Genre:
- horror-suspense
- Reprints: show reprint note before migration
Last page is printed on the inside back cover.
- Pencils:
- Ken Kelly (painted)
- Inks:
- Ken Kelly (painted)
- Colors:
- Ken Kelly (painted)
- Genre:
- horror-suspense
- Reprints: show reprint note before migration
Back cover. Image is the same as the front cover, but without the title and trade dress.