Notes:
1986 - Favorite Publication about Comics - Amazing Heroes

1993 - Favorite Publication about Comics - Wizard: The Guide to Comics

1996 - Favorite Reprint Graphic Novel or Album - Carl Barks Library

1997 - Favorite Comic Book - Kurt Busiek's Astro City

1997 - Favorite Reprint Graphic Novel or Album - KBAC: Life in the Big City

1998 - Favorite Publisher - DC

1999 - Favorite Publisher - DC

2000 - Favorite Publisher - DC

2001 - Favorite Publisher - DC

2002 - Favorite Publisher - DC

2003 - Favorite Publisher - DC

2004 - Favorite Publisher – DC
Name Recipient Year Awarded
Favorite Editor Jim Shooter 1984
Favorite Story Alan Moore 1985
Favorite Writer Alan Moore 1985
Favorite Colorist Lynn Varley 1986
Favorite Comic Book (title) Swamp Thing (1985 series) 1986
Favorite Comic Book Story Batman: The Dark Knight (1986 series) 1986
Favorite Cover Artist George Pérez 1986
Favorite Direct-Sales Only Title (Phil Seuling Award) Watchmen (1986 series) 1986
Favorite Editor Denny O'Neil 1986
Favorite Graphic Novel Daredevil / Elektra: Love and War (2003 series) 1986
Favorite Inker Terry Austin 1986
Favorite Letterer John Costanza 1986
Favorite Limited Comic Book Series Batman: The Dark Knight (1986 series) 1986
Favorite Penciller John Byrne 1986
Favorite Writer Alan Moore 1986
Favorite Writer Alan Moore 1987
Favorite Penciller George Pérez 1988
Best Limited Series Batman (1940 series) 1990
Best Writer Marv Wolfman 1990
Favorite Colorist Olyoptics 1992
Favorite Cover Artist Brian Bolland 1992
Favorite Editor ? Mike Carlin 1992?
Favorite Inker Scott Williams 1992
Favorite Letterer Tom Orzechowski 1992
Favorite Painter Todd McFarlane 1992
Favorite Writer Neil Gaiman 1992
Best Achievement by a Letterer Tom Orzechowski 1993
Favorite Colorist Olyoptics 1993
Favorite Comic Book Sandman (1989 series) 1993
Favorite Comic Book Story Action Comics (1938 series) 1993
Favorite Cover Artist Brian Bolland 1993
Favorite Editor Mike Carlin 1993
Favorite Inker Scott Williams 1993
Favorite Letterer Tom Orzechowski 1993
Favorite Original Graphic Novel or Album Superman: Speeding Bullets (1993 series) 1993
Favorite Painter Joe Jusko 1993
Favorite Penciller Todd McFarlane 1993
Favorite Reprint Graphic Novel or Album The Death of Superman (1993 series) [First Printing] 1993
Favorite Writer Neil Gaiman 1993
Comics Buyer's Guide Award Favorite Writer Peter David 1994
Favorite Colorist Tom McCraw 1995
Favorite Colorist Tom McCraw 1996
Favorite Comic Book Walt Disney's Uncle Scrooge Adventures (1993 series) 1996
Favorite Comic Book Story Horsing Around with History (Uncle Scrooge) comic story, 24p 1996
Favorite Cover Artist Alex Ross 1996
Favorite Editor Bob Harras 1996
Favorite Inker Pat Block 1996
Favorite Letterer William Van Horn 1996
Favorite Limited Comic-Book Series Sin City: The Big Fat Kill (1994 series) 1996
Favorite Original Graphic Novel or Album Sandman Midnight Theatre (1995 series) 1996
Favorite Painter Alex Ross 1996
Favorite Penciller William Van Horn 1996
Favorite Writer Carl Barks 1996
Favorite Colorist Greg Wright 1997
Favorite Colorist Greg Wright 1997
Favorite Comic-Book Story Kingdom Come (1997 series) 1997
Favorite Cover Artist Alex Ross 1997
Favorite Editor Mark Gruenwald 1997
Favorite Inker Terry Austin 1997
Favorite Letterer Richard Starkings 1997
Favorite Letterer Comicraft 1997
Favorite Original Graphic Novel or Album Batman / Captain America (1996 series) 1997
Favorite Painter Alex Ross 1997
Favorite Penciller John Byrne 1997
Favorite Reprint Graphic Album Kingdom Come (1996 series) 1997
Favorite Writer Mark Waid 1997
Favorite Colorist Lovern Kindzierski 1998
Favorite Comic Book Kurt Busiek's Astro City (1996 series) 1998
Favorite Cover Artist Alex Ross 1998
Favorite Editor Archie Goodwin 1998
Favorite Inker Terry Austin 1998
Favorite Letterer Richard Starkings 1998
Favorite Letterer Comicraft 1998
Favorite Limited Series Batman: The Long Halloween (1996 series) 1998
Favorite Original Graphic Novel Sin City: Family Values (1997 series) 1998
Favorite Painter Alex Ross 1998
Favorite Reprint Graphic Album Kingdom Come (1997 series) 1998
Favorite Story Kurt Busiek's Astro City (1996 series) 1998
Favorite Writer Kurt Busiek 1998
Favorite Colorist Lynn Varley 1999
Favorite Comic Book Avengers (1998 series) 1999
Favorite Editor Tom Brevoort 1999
Favorite Inker Al Vey 1999
Favorite Letterer Richard Starkings 1999
Favorite Letterer Comicraft 1999
Favorite Limited Series Superman for All Seasons (1998 series) 1999
Favorite Original Graphic Novel The New Adventures of Abraham Lincoln (1998 series) 1999
Favorite Painter Alex Ross 1999
Favorite Penciller George Pérez 1999
Favorite Reprint Graphic Album Plastic Man Archives (1998 series) #1 1999
Favorite Story Superman for All Seasons (1998 series) 1999
Favorite Writer Alan Moore 1999
Favorite Writer Kurt Busiek 1999
Favorite Colorist Lynn Varley 2000
Favorite Comic Book Avengers Forever (1998 series) 2000
Favorite Cover Artist Alex Ross 2000
Favorite Editor Denny O'Neil 2000
Favorite Inker Al Vey 2000
Favorite Letterer Todd Klein 2000
Favorite Limited Series Avengers Forever (1998 series) 2000