Otto's aunt Sally Lee sends him a lamp, which turns out to have a genie who will grant a single wish. Since orange is Otto's favorite color, he wishes that everything were orange.
Otto enjoys the orange world but discovers that orange pork chops and orange milk are unappealing, while traffic ties up because all the lights are orange. He consults Aunt Sally Lee, who has an idea.
Aunt Sally Lee buys the lamp back for a nickel, entitling her to one wish as the new owner. She wishes to undo Otto's wish, but the mischievous genie just turns everything blue, instead of orange. Otto orders pizza, and the genie agrees that blue pizza won't do. He restores everything to proper colors, and Otto agrees that while orange is great, all the other colors are great too.