- Script
- ?
- Pencils
- Chris Bachalo (credited)
- Inks
- Art Thibert (credited)
- Letters
- ?
- Characters
- Ms. White [Amanda Collins]
Inside front cover indicia/credits page illustrated with black and white version of artwork from The Witching Hour (DC, 1999 series) #1, page 47.
- Script
- Jeph Loeb (credited); Chris Bachalo ?
- Pencils
- Chris Bachalo (credited)
- Inks
- Art Thibert (credited)
- Colors
- Grant Goleash (credited); Digital Chameleon (credited) (separations)
- Letters
- Richard Starkings (credited)
- Genre
- fantasy-supernatural; horror-suspense
- Characters
- Ms. White [Amanda Collins]; Dr. Shindler Lake; Gray [Aleister]; Caleb Stone; Heather; Charity; Black; Dexter Grimes; Red; Amy; Blue; Ed
- Synopsis
- Recipients of wishes find out that there are consequences for their choices. Amanda Collins tells the story of her emigration to America and execution during the Salem witch trials.
- Reprints
Story title from previous issue.
Loeb & Bachalo credited as "storytellers," but interview in Vertigo: Winter's Edge (DC, 1998 series) #3 (January 2000) suggests Bachalo mostly did art. Story has a mix of black and white and color art.
- Script
- ?
- Pencils
- Chris Bachalo (credited)
- Inks
- Art Thibert (credited)
- Colors
- Grant Goleash ?
- Letters
- ? (typeset text & "runic" title)
- Genre
- fantasy-supernatural; horror-suspense
- Characters
- Dexter Grimes; Amy; Charity; Ms. White [Amanda Collins]; Gray [Aleister]; Blue; Black; Red
Illustrated with colored versions of black and white art from The Witching Hour (DC, 1999 series) #1, pages 6, 10, 15, 24, & 28 and from #2, pages 11, 15, & 21.
On back cover.