The Crypt-Keeper (host); Eileen Harper (Ben's wife); Ben Harper (Sultana's 1st Mate, death); Captain Matt Starke (villain, Sultana skipper)
A sea captain murders a man for his wife by having him row out to a plague island where he contracts the disease. When he is rotting away they toss him overboard, but a whale swallows him and then vomits him back up. The captain knows the spew is valuable for perfume so he collects it and presents it to the murdered man's wife where she dons it in the bathroom and opens the door to reveal her instantaneously rotting flesh.
The Vault-Keeper (host); Hannah (Irwin's wife, death); Bert; Irwin (villain)
Irwin was telling his neighbor Bert about how he and his wife Hannah fell in love and how Hannah loved expensive chocolates so much. She got fatter as he had to make do without vital necessities, and Irwin just couldn't take it anymore. Irwin admitted to killing her and asked Bert to come over to his house. As they walked in, Bert gasped in horror as he spotted a giant, handmade chocolate box, marked with different types of candy, and pieces of Hannah in each part!
An escaped convict beats in a woman's skull with a club in order to steal her food out in a shack set in the swamp. The convict looks up from his meal, only to see a huge hulking brute of a man looking at him. He flees in terror only to have the brute follow him clutching the club. He faces several dangers of the swamp, yet still the brute pursues with the club. Finally, he can go no further, and begs for mercy. The brute ignores his pleas and hands him back the club, telling him he forgot it at his house and leaving him mentally unhinged from the stress.