Raymond Schneider; Pearl Bahmer; Edward Garrigan; James Curran; Albert Cardinal; Leon Loblein; Edward W. Hall; Bogart F. Conkling; George Totten; William H. Long; Edwin R. Carpender; Samuel Sutphen; Eleanor Mills
Synopsis
In New Brunswick, 1922, the dead bodies of Rev. Hall and Eleanor Mills are found lying in a park with love letters strewn around.
Edward W. Hall; Eleanor Mills; Frances Hall; Willie Stevens; James Mills; Charlotte Mills; Daniel Mills; Azariah Beekman; Joseph E. Stricker; Frances Voorhees; Louise Geist; Millie Opie; John Meany; Agnes Blust; Cedric Paulus; William Phillips; Harry Kolb; Runkle Hegeman
Synopsis
The police begin an investigation into Rev. Hall and Eleanor's deaths.
Raymond Schneider; Pearl Bahmer; Edward W. Hall; Eleanor Mills; Frances Hall; Willie Stevens; Charlotte Mills; Azariah Beekman; Clifford Hayes; Leon Kaufman; Nick Bahmer; Thomas McCran; Henry Stevens; John Anderson; Wilbur A. Mott; James F. Mason; Jane Gibson; Henry Carpender; Charles Parker
Synopsis
The murder investigation becomes a media circus as false accusations and glory-seekers emerge, while others sell evidence to the newspapers instead of submitting it to the police. The police are unable to build a case.
Frances Hall; Willie Stevens; James Mills; Charlotte Mills; Louise Geist; Henry Stevens; Jane Gibson; Henry Carpender; Charles Parker; Arthur Riehl; Peter Tumulty; Philip Payne; A. Harry Moore; Alexander Simpson; Robert McCarter; Frank Cleary; Otto Schultze; Francis Bergen; Clarence E. Case; Ralph Gorseline; Catherine Rastall; Elsie Barnhardt
Synopsis
After four years of inactivity new evidence prompts the case to be re-opened. This time Rev. Hall's wife is prosecuted for the crime along with three men from her family, but a jury finds them not guilty.