Cover and indicia title is Archie's Christmas Stocking.
On sale date as listed in the Catalog of Copyright Entries, 1957 Books, Pamphlets, Serials, Contributions to Periodicals, page 950 as stated: Archie's Christmas Stocking No. 4, 1957 edition. Application author: John L. Goldwater © Archie Comic Publications, Inc.; 4 October 1957; registration number A313152.
Later redrawn for the cover of Archie Comics Digest #16
Hiram Lodge is called "Jayson" in this story.
Crossword puzzle with pictures as clues.
Superintendent is misspelled as "Superintendant".