Previous indexer credited Estrada drawing the female and Infantino the male but Nick Caputo suspects it is Estrada pencils based on an Infantino layout.
The splash page of this story is a modified version of the cover of Heart Throbs (DC, 1957 series) #83. Annette's hair has been changed here (a shorter style with no pony tail) and that style is used throughout the story. This story was probably touched-up from the original story to make it seem less dated when it was reprinted.
The image of the female on the cover is taken from the splash page of this story.