- Pencils
- ?
- Inks
- ?
- Colors
- ?
- Letters
- ?
Title page with illustration
- Pencils
- ?
- Inks
- ?
- Colors
- ?
- Letters
- ?; typeset
Title pages with creator credits, includes illustration
- Pencils
- Jesús Merino
- Inks
- Jesús Merino
- Colors
- Ulises Arreola
- Letters
- typeset
- Characters
- Mad Hatter [Jervis Tetch]; Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; Poison Ivy [Pamela Isley]; Killer Croc [Waylon Jones]; Catwoman [Selina Kyle]; Mister Freeze [Victor Fries]; Bane; Professor Pyg [Lazlo Valentin]
Indicia and publisher information, with illustration from The Joker Presents: A Puzzlebox #2.
- Pencils
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Inks
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Colors
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker
- Reprints
Color art from issue cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Script
- Matthew Rosenberg (credited)
- Pencils
- Jesús Merino (credited); Joshua Hixson (credited)
- Inks
- Jesús Merino (credited); Joshua Hixson (credited)
- Colors
- Ulises Arreola (credited); Joshua Hixson (credited)
- Letters
- Ferran Delgado (credited)
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Commissioner James Gordon; Harvey Bullock; Mad Hatter; Black Mask; Professor Pyg; Killer Croc; Two-Face; Killer Moth; Poison Ivy; Man-Bat; Harley Quinn; Mister Freeze; Deathstroke; Penguin; Scarecrow; Bane; Catwoman; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Nightwing [Dick Grayson]; Batgirl [Barbara Gordon]; Robin [Tim Drake]; Detective Mercedes Olvera; Bachman; Riddler [Edward Nygma]; Dr. Caro; Punchline
- Synopsis
- Batman and the Gotham Police break up a gathering of villains and arrest them all. Once in custody, Gordon and Bullock interview the Joker to determine if he played a role in the murder of the Riddler. In flashback, we see the Riddler pursuing a mysterious box and offering to partner with the Joker, but the Joker turns him down.
- Reprints
- Pencils
- Chris Mooneyham (credited)
- Inks
- Chris Mooneyham (credited)
- Characters
- The Joker
Illustration from the Chris Mooneyham Variant Cover of The Joker Presents: A Puzzlebox #1.
- Pencils
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Inks
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Colors
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- Catwoman; Two-Face; Harley Quinn; Mad Hatter; Black Mask
- Reprints
Color art from issue cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Script
- Matthew Rosenberg (credited)
- Pencils
- Jesús Merino (credited); Keron Grant (credited); Dani Dacquin (credited as Dani)
- Inks
- Jesús Merino (credited); Keron Grant (credited); Dani Dacquin (credited as Dani)
- Colors
- Ulises Arreola (credited); Keron Grant (credited); Jeromy Cox (credited)
- Letters
- Ferran Delgado (credited)
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Commissioner James Gordon; Harvey Bullock; Black Mask; Mr. Brill; Dima; Two-Face; Crispus Allen; Renee Montoya; Harley Quinn; Bolly; Mad Hatter; Killer Croc; Mr. Oliver; Officer Saporta; Poison Ivy; Mister Freeze; Bane; Professor Pyg
- Synopsis
- Gordon and Bullock continue their interview the Joker to find out who killed the Riddler, while Detectives Allen and Montoya interrogate Black Mask. In flashback, we see Black Mask travels to Russia to acquire one of the mystery artifacts, but he is not the only Gotham villain interested in it. Also, Harley Quinn tracks another of the artifacts where she has an encounter with Mad Hatter.
- Reprints
- Pencils
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Inks
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Colors
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Two-Face [Harvey Dent]
- Reprints
Color art from issue cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Script
- Matthew Rosenberg (credited)
- Pencils
- Jesús Merino (credited); Dominike Stanton (credited as Dominike 'Domo' Stanton); Juni Ba (credited)
- Inks
- Jesús Merino (credited); Dominike Stanton (credited as Dominike 'Domo' Stanton); Juni Ba (credited)
- Colors
- Ulises Arreola (credited); Mike Spicer (credited); Nick Filardi (credited)
- Letters
- Ferran Delgado (credited)
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Commissioner James Gordon; Harvey Bullock; Detective Crowe; Two-Face [Harvey Dent]; Catwoman [Selina Kyle]; Deathstroke [Slade Wilson]; Doctor Phosphorous; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Black Mask [Roman Sionis]; Man-Bat [Kirk Langstrom]; Killer Moth; Penguin [Oswald Cobblepot]; Mad Hatter [Jervis Tetch]; Harley Quinn; Poison Ivy; Scarecrow [Jonathan Crane]; Bane; Killer Croc; Mister Freeze [Victor Fries]; Professor Pyg; Officer Walter Bachman; Officer Walsh
- Synopsis
- Gordon and Bullock continue to interrogate the Joker, while other detectives interrogate Two-Face, trying to piece together the events that led to the murder of the Riddler. In flashback, we see The Joker pay Two-Face a visit, leading to Harvey confronting Deathstroke over possession of one of the artifacts, while Catwoman sends Man-Bat to get one of the other artifacts that Killer Moth is after.
- Reprints
Story is incorrectly labeled Chapter 5, it should be Chapter 3.
- Pencils
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Inks
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Colors
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Reprints
Color art from issue cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Script
- Matthew Rosenberg (credited)
- Pencils
- Jesús Merino (credited); Vanesa Del Rey (credited); Ricardo López Ortiz (credited as Ricardo Lopez Ortiz)
- Inks
- Jesús Merino (credited); Vanesa Del Rey (credited); Ricardo López Ortiz (credited as Ricardo Lopez Ortiz)
- Colors
- Ulises Arreola (credited); Eva de la Cruz (credited); Tony Aviña (credited)
- Letters
- Ferran Delgado (credited)
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Commissioner James Gordon; Harvey Bullock; Mad Hatter [Jervis Tetch]; Penguin [Oswald Cobblepot]; Bane; Tweedledee; Tweedledum; Poison Ivy [Pamela Isley]; Black Mask [Roman Sionis]; Mr. Oliver; Officer Anderson; Crispus Allen; Renee Montoya; Professor Pyg [Lazlo Valentin]; Scarecrow [Jonathan Crane]; Catwoman [Selina Kyle]; Deathstroke; Killer Croc [Waylon Jones]; Killer Moth; Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]
- Synopsis
- Gordon and Bullock continue to interrogate the Joker, while Allen and Montoya interrogate Mad Hatter. In flashback, we see Penguin try to outwit Bane to gain possession of one of the artifacts, and Professor Pyg and Scarecrow compete to obtain another of the artifacts.
- Reprints
Story is incorrectly labeled Chapter 7, it should be Chapter 4.
- Pencils
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Inks
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Colors
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker [as The Riddler]
- Reprints
Color art from issue cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Script
- Matthew Rosenberg (credited)
- Pencils
- Jesús Merino (credited); Chris Mooneyham (credited); Freddie Williams II (credited as Freddie E. Williams II)
- Inks
- Jesús Merino (credited); Chris Mooneyham (credited); Freddie Williams II (credited as Freddie E. Williams II)
- Colors
- Ulises Arreola (credited); Roman Stevens (credited)
- Letters
- Ferran Delgado (credited)
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Commissioner James Gordon; Harvey Bullock; Killer Moth [Drury Walker]; Two-Face [Harvey Dent]; Catwoman [Selina Kyle]; Man-Bat [Kirk Langstrom]; Penguin [Oswald Cobblepot]; Mad Hatter [Jervis Tetch]; Scarecrow [Jonathan Crane]; Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; Professor Pyg [Lazlo Valentin]; Bane; Black Mask [Roman Sionis]; Poison Ivy [Pamela Isley]; Killer Croc [Waylon Jones]; Riddler [Edward Nygma]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Deathstroke [Slade Wilson]; Crispus Allen; Renee Montoya; Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Officer Walter Bachman
- Synopsis
- As Gordon and Bullock continue their interrogation, The Joker tells them how three teams of villains converged on a deserted warehouse to battle each other for possession of the Master Engine. According to the Joker, it was the Riddler who was behind everything, but as Gotham's finest interrogate the other villains they hear differing accounts of the battle, and the other villains are all consistent in denying that the Riddler was present.
- Reprints
Story is incorrectly labeled Chapter 9, it should be Chapter 5.
- Pencils
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Inks
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Colors
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker
- Reprints
Color art from issue cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Script
- Matthew Rosenberg (credited)
- Pencils
- Juan Doe (credited); Shawn Crystal (credited); Vicente Cifuentes (credited); Jesús Merino (credited)
- Inks
- Juan Doe (credited); Vicente Cifuentes (credited); Jesús Merino (credited)
- Colors
- Juan Doe (credited); Ulises Arreola (credited)
- Letters
- Ferran Delgado (credited)
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Commissioner James Gordon; Harvey Bullock; Clayface [Basil Karlo; also as Batman]; Riddler [Edward Nygma]; Mister Freeze [Victor Fries]; Penguin [Oswald Cobblepot]; Killer Moth [Drury Walker]; Deathstroke [Slade Wilson]; Poison Ivy [Pamela Isley]; Punchline [Alexis Kaye]; Mad Hatter [Jervis Tetch]; Catwoman [Selina Kyle]; Two-Face [Harvey Dent]; Scarecrow [Jonathan Crane]; Man-Bat [Kirk Langstrom]; Black Mask [Roman Sionis]; Bane; Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; Killer Croc [Waylon Jones]; Professor Pyg [Lazlo Valentin]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Nightwing [Dick Grayson]; Batgirl [Barbara Gordon]; Renee Montoya; Sefert; Nadler; Jenkins
- Synopsis
- As Gordon and Bullock continue their interrogation, The Joker tells them how Clayface posing as Batman stole the Master Engine but was stopped by Mister Freeze. At GCPD, Mister Freeze escapes and attempts to kill the Joker. Gordon tells the Joker what he believes are the true events that led to the Riddler's death.
- Reprints
- Pencils
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Inks
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Colors
- Chip Zdarsky (credited) (signed as )
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker
- Reprints
Color art from issue cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Script
- Matthew Rosenberg (credited)
- Pencils
- Mike Norton (credited); Jesús Merino (credited); Vicente Cifuentes (credited)
- Inks
- Mike Norton (credited); Jesús Merino (credited); Vicente Cifuentes (credited)
- Colors
- Roman Stevens (credited); Ulises Arreola (credited)
- Letters
- Ferran Delgado (credited)
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Commissioner James Gordon; Harvey Bullock; Scarecrow [Jonathan Crane]; Bane; Killer Croc [Waylon Jones]; Mad Hatter [Jervis Tetch]; Deathstroke [Slade Wilson]; Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; Penguin [Oswald Cobblepot]; Poison Ivy [Pamela Isley]; Professor Pyg [Lazlo Valentin]; Killer Moth [Drury Walker]; Mister Freeze [Victor Fries]; Black Mask [Roman Sionis]; Man-Bat [Kirk Langstrom]; Punchline [Alexis Kaye]; Catwoman [Selina Kyle]; Clayface [Basil Karlo; also as The Joker]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Two-Face [Harvey Dent]; Riddler [Edward Nygma]; Doctor Phosphorous; Toyman [Winslow Schott]; Olvera; Bachman
- Synopsis
- As Gordon and Bullock try to understand the Joker's game, bombs planted around the city by the Joker detonate, including one at police headquarters. The Joker escapes in the confusion, aided by Punchline. As Batman arrives to stop the other villains from escaping, the Joker reveals his master plan to Punchline and how he staged the death of the Riddler to confuse everyone into trying to figure out who killed him.
- Reprints
Story is incorrectly labeled Chapter 13, it should be Chapter 7.
- Pencils
- Miguel Mendonça (credited)
- Inks
- Miguel Mendonça (credited)
- Colors
- Enrica Eren Angiolini (credited)
- Letters
- ?
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker
Introduction to the variant cover gallery, with illustration from the variant cover of The Joker Presents: A Puzzlebox #6.
- Pencils
- Chris Mooneyham (credited) (signed as Chris Mooneyham)
- Inks
- Chris Mooneyham (credited) (signed as Chris Mooneyham)
- Colors
- Chris Mooneyham (credited) (signed as Chris Mooneyham)
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker
- Reprints
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Jesús Merino (credited)
- Inks
- Jesús Merino (credited)
- Colors
- Ulises Arreola (credited)
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker
- Reprints
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Riccardo Federici (credited) (signed as )
- Inks
- Riccardo Federici (credited) (signed as )
- Colors
- Riccardo Federici (credited) (signed as )
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Catwoman [Selina Kyle]; Killer Croc [Waylon Jones]; Scarecrow [Jonathan Crane]; Mister Freeze [Victor Fries]; Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; Penguin [Oswald Cobblepot]; Bane
- Reprints
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Tiago da Silva (credited) (signed as Tiago da Silva)
- Inks
- Tiago da Silva (credited) (signed as Tiago da Silva)
- Colors
- Tiago da Silva (credited) (signed as Tiago da Silva)
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Deathstroke; Penguin; Catwoman; Scarecrow; Poison Ivy
- Reprints
- Keywords
- playing cards
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Megan Hutchison (credited as Megan Hutchison-Cates)
- Inks
- Megan Hutchison (credited as Megan Hutchison-Cates)
- Colors
- Megan Hutchison (credited as Megan Hutchison-Cates)
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Poison Ivy; Bane; Scarface
- Reprints
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
Artist's name is misspelled as Megan Hutchinson-Cates.
- Pencils
- David Choe (credited)
- Inks
- David Choe (credited)
- Colors
- David Choe (credited)
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker
- Reprints
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Zoe Lacchei (credited, signed)
- Inks
- Zoe Lacchei (credited, signed)
- Colors
- Zoe Lacchei (credited, signed)
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Harley Quinn
- Reprints
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Ryan Brown (credited) (signed as )
- Inks
- Ryan Brown (credited) (signed as )
- Colors
- Ryan Brown (credited) (signed as )
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Harley Quinn
- Reprints
- Keywords
- jigsaw puzzle
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Shawn Crystal
- Inks
- Shawn Crystal
- Colors
- Juan Doe (credited)
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- Harley Quinn; Black Mask
- Reprints
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Reilly Brown (credited) (signed as Reilly Brown)
- Inks
- Reilly Brown (credited) (signed as Reilly Brown)
- Colors
- Jim Charalampidis (credited)
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- Riddler; Mister Freeze; Harley Quinn; Two-Face; Penguin; Man-Bat; Bane; Deathstroke
- Reprints
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Ryan Brown (credited) (signed as )
- Inks
- Ryan Brown (credited) (signed as )
- Colors
- Ryan Brown (credited) (signed as )
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- Scarecrow [Jonathan Crane]; Professor Pyg [Lazlo Valentin]
- Reprints
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Davi Go (credited) (signed as DAVI GO)
- Inks
- Davi Go (credited) (signed as DAVI GO)
- Colors
- Davi Go (credited) (signed as DAVI GO)
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker; Riddler [Edward Nygma] (silhouette)
- Reprints
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Miguel Mendonça (credited, signed)
- Inks
- Miguel Mendonça (credited, signed)
- Colors
- Enrica Eren Angiolini (credited)
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- The Joker
- Reprints
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Reilly Brown (credited) (signed as Reilly Brown)
- Inks
- Reilly Brown (credited) (signed as Reilly Brown)
- Colors
- Jim Charalampidis (credited) (signed as JC)
- Letters
- typeset
- Genre
- superhero
- Characters
- Deathstroke [Slade Wilson]; Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; Two-Face [Harvey Dent]; The Joker; Catwoman [Selina Kyle]; Bane; Penguin [Oswald Cobblepot]
- Reprints
Color art from issue variant cover with no logos, numbers, and pricing.
- Pencils
- Freddie Williams II (credited as Freddie E. Williams II)
- Letters
- typeset
3-D Models by Freddie E. Williams II
- Pencils
- Jesús Merino (credited)
- Letters
- typeset
Page layouts
- Script
- ?
- Pencils
- Chris Mooneyham ?
- Inks
- Chris Mooneyham ?
- Colors
- ?
- Letters
- typeset
- Characters
- Catwoman [Selina Kyle]; Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; Penguin [Oswald Cobblepot]; Two-Face [Harvey Dent]; Professor Pyg [Lazlo Valentin]; Bane; Man-Bat [Kirk Langstrom]; Killer Moth [Drury Walker]; Mad Hatter [Jervis Tetch]; Killer Croc [Waylon Jones]; Scarecrow [Jonathan Crane]; Black Mask [Roman Sionis]
Back cover with text on contents of collection, includes illustration from The Joker Presents: A Puzzlebox #5.