- Script
- Al Feldstein (co-plot, script); Bill Gaines (co-plot)
- Pencils
- Graham Ingels
- Inks
- Graham Ingels
- Colors
- ?
- Letters
- Jim Wroten
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- The Old Witch (host)
- Reprints
Script credit from Tales of Terror: The EC Companion.
- Script
- Al Feldstein (co-plot, script); Bill Gaines (co-plot)
- Pencils
- George Evans
- Inks
- George Evans
- Colors
- ?
- Letters
- Jim Wroten
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- The Vault-Keeper (host)
- Reprints
Script credit from Tales of Terror: The EC Companion.
- Script
- Chris Rock (credited as The Old Witch)
- Pencils
- Graham Ingels
- Inks
- Graham Ingels
- Letters
- typeset
Letters from Curtis Reck (plus fan art), Joe Grotenrath II, Richard Jaeger, David Dellario, Tony Todero, and Bob Gorby.
- Script
- Chris Rock (credited as The Crypt-Keeper)
- Pencils
- ?
- Inks
- ?
- Letters
- typeset
Fan art by David A. Barber, Rick Olson, and Joe Grotenrath II; poem by Frank X. Mattson.
- Script
- Al Feldstein (co-plot, script); Bill Gaines (co-plot)
- Pencils
- Jack Kamen
- Inks
- Jack Kamen
- Colors
- ?
- Letters
- Jim Wroten
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- The Old Witch (host)
- Reprints
Script credit from Tales of Terror: The EC Companion.