Archie arrives as a counselor at the same camp where Mr. Weatherbee is working. Archie puts Mr. Weatherbee's trunk away, and Reggie and Jughead take the trunk. They throw it in the lake as part of the camp initiation, not knowing it is Mr. Weatherbee's.
Mr. Weatherbee finds Archie at the swimming hole, and orders him to leave. On his way back to camp, Archie knocks down a sign and Mr. Weatherbee gets lost in the woods. Archie then uses the natural attraction between him and Mr. Weatherbee to find Mr. Weatherbee.
Archie and Reggie try to make Betty and Veronica appreciate Jughead by making it seem that Jughead can predict the future. However, the plan backfires when Betty and Veronica begin to only care for Jughead.