- Roy Thomas (credited)
- Rich Buckler (credited)
- Jerry Ordway (credited)
- Carl Gafford (credited)
- John Costanza (credited)
- Job Number:
- All-Star Squadron [Robotman; Liberty Belle; Johnny Quick; Shining Knight; Plastic Man (flashback)]; Phantom Lady (flashback)]; Danette Reilly (does not appear as Firebrand); Justice Society of America [Superman (Earth-2); Batman (Earth-2); Robin (Earth-2); Wonder Woman (Earth-2); Spectre [Jim Corrigan (Earth-2)]; Dr. Fate [Kent Nelson; Nabu]; Johnny Thunder; Johnny Thunder's Thunderbolt; Hawkman [Carter Hall]; Sandman [Wesley Dodds]; Dr. Mid-Nite [Charles McNider]; Atom [Al Pratt]; Green Lantern [Alan Scott]]; Dragon King (intro, villain); Slugger Dunn; Rod Reilly (does not appear as Firebrand); Adolf Hitler (flashback); Tojo (flashback)
- When both teams return to Pearl Harbor and see the damage, the more powerful of the heroes go to defend an island under siege by the Japanese in the Pacific. They arrive, with the others in tow, but slowly begin to fall under both the Holy Tablet (supposedly carved from part of the Holy Grail itself) and the Spear of Destiny's combined magicks (both held by Tojo and Hitler respectively). The others must then fight them and get them back to territory not under Axis control/influence. In Washington, D.C., FDR has declared all heroes as All-Star members now for World War II's duration.
- Holy Grail; Pearl Harbor; Spear of Destiny; World War II
Story continued from All-Star Squadron #3; continues in part in All-Star Squadron #5.
References All-Star Comics #9 and DC Special #29.
Presented in three chapters: Chapter One is "Day of the Dragon King!" (5 pages), Chapter Two is "Aftermath of Infamy!" (8 pages), Chapter Three is "What Price Vengeance?" (14 pages).
- Roy Thomas [as RT] (credited)
- Job Number:
Letters from Junior Kerns, Albert Feichenbach, Mike Dennier, Paul Blaze, Dan Coakley, Dean Rollings, and Mark Lagasse.
Includes letters reviewing the All-Star Squadron story in Justice League of America #193.