- Script
- Len Wein (co-plotter, scripter); E. Nelson Bridwell (co-plotter)
- Pencils
- Curt Swan
- Inks
- Murphy Anderson
- Colors
- Gene D'Angelo
- Letters
- Ben Oda
- Genre
- superhero; fantasy-supernatural
- Characters
- Superman; Santa Claus; Toyman [Winslow P. Schott] (villain); Timmy Dickens; Krypton (flashback); Krypto (flashback); Baby Kal-El (flashback); Santa's Elves; Santa's Reindeer
- Synopsis
- Santa Claus helps Superman stop Toyman and replaces all the Christmas toys that Toyman rigged for evil.
- Reprints
- Keywords
- Fortress of Solitude; green kryptonite
Credits for script, pencils and inks confirmed from Julius Schwartz's editorial records, provided by DC Comics.
- Script
- Bob Rozakis
- Pencils
- José Luis García-López
- Inks
- ?
- Colors
- ?
- Letters
- typeset
- Job Number
- S-4293
Letters from Wallace Lee Hopkins, Adam Burchess, Kevin T. Brown, D. Rousse, Michael D. Welch, Dennis K. Catucci, Don Jackson, Kevin Guzman, Mike Hamlet, Steve Brown, Jackie Davison, and David Trapena.