Joe Tyler (story); Ralph Tedesco (story); Linda Ly (writer); Raven Gregory (writer)
Stephen Chambers; Sara; Lucy; Belinda; Little Mermaid; Sea Witch; The Prince
Lucy's plan to have Stephen fall in love with Sara seems to be working until Sara discovers that Stephen was just using her and is now seeing someone else. Belinda gives Lucy a gun that Sara takes to Stephen's apartment. She fires a shot into a vase, but can't bring herself to shoot Stephen. The police arrive and arrest Sara, now pregnant. This mirrors the fairy tale Lucy never finished where the Little Mermaid can break her deal with the Sea Witch by killing the Prince, but she can't bring herself to do it and ends up being killed by the Sea Witch.