Jay Garrick witnesses the murder of a man who has been dumped into a river off a bridge. He is arrested, but soon after the scene is repeated again, and another Jay Garrick is arrested. The question is: what is going on?
When Jay Garrick arrives at the monthly meeting of the Liars Club, he is fascinated by a surrealist painting just purchased by the club. However, Jay tells the story of a weirder painting: one in which the Flash stepped into in order to discover the whereabouts of a man who had disappeared into it.