Justice Society of America [Dr. Fate; Flash [Jay Garrick]; Green Lantern [Alan Scott]; Hawkman [Carter Hall]; Wildcat [Ted Grant]; Hourman [Rex Tyler]; Power Girl; Robin (Earth-2); Star-Spangled Kid [Sylvester Pemberton]; Starman [Ted Knight]; Dr. Mid-Nite [Charles McNider]; Wonder Woman (Earth-2); Superman (Earth-2)]; Huntress [Helena Wayne] (introduction, cameo); Gotham City Police Commissioner Bruce Wayne (Earth-2); Psycho-Pirate [Roger Hayden](image only); Catwoman [Selina Kyle Wayne] (flashback)
The JSA is divided against itself with one group -- consisting of Hawkman, Green Lantern, Flash, Star Spangled Kid, Wildcat, Dr. Fate -- facing off against a group with Commissioner Bruce Wayne behind them -- Robin, Wonder Woman, Starman, Dr. Mid-Nite, Hourman -- seeking to arrest the others on trumped up charges. Though Power Girl is hurt, Superman and Dr. Fate save the day when Superman stops the fight and Fate reveals that Commissioner Wayne is being controlled by the Psycho Pirate.