Batman; Robin [Jason Todd]; Commissioner Gordon; Alfred Pennyworth; Rachel Caspian; Professor Paxton; Grace Paxton [also as The Reaper]; District Attorney Paul Samuels; Leslie Thompkins; Nails Norkofsky; Tommy Garnett; McSurley; Johnny Garnett [also as The Reaper]
Batman and Robin's latest surveillance is disrupted by the return of The Reaper, but the vigilante escapes. He returns when the two major mob families meet, leaving enough clues behind for the Darknight Detective to figure out the game, rescue Rachel Caspian, and put an end to the latest spree of The Reaper.
Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Commissioner Jim Gordon; Rachel Caspian; Reaper [Judson Caspian]; Leslie Thompkins; Alfred Pennyworth; Thomas Wayne (in portrait); Martha Wayne (in portrait)
A vigilante called the Reaper, who operated in Gotham City twenty years earlier, re-emerges just as Bruce Wayne begins a relationship with Rachel Caspian, though neither Bruce nor Rachel know that her father is the Reaper. After being badly beaten by the Reaper in their first encounter, Batman decides to use the very gun used to kill his parents to bring the Reaper down.