- Script
- ?
- Pencils
- Alex Toth
- Inks
- Dick Giordano
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Murray Boltinoff (original credited editor); E. Nelson Bridwell (actual original editor)
- Job Number
- [G-138]; [N-785]
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- Come, dear reader, come along!
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Cynthia; Mildred; Mordred
- Reprints
The table of contents in The Witching Hour (DC, 1969 series) 38 (January 1974) calls this story "Meet the Three Witches". "Witching Hour Spectacular" is a page header in that issue, but reads as a story title on this sequence because the page header stops after the first page and is only used on a few later stories in this issue.
- Script
- Dave Kaler (credited as David Kaler)
- Pencils
- Reginald Pitt (layouts, credited); Stanley Pitt (credited)
- Inks
- Stanley Pitt (credited)
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Murray Boltinoff (original credited editor); E. Nelson Bridwell (actual original editor)
- Job Number
- G-229
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- Since the time is ripe for tales, let me pluck one out of the shadows of the African jungle!
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Cynthia (host)
- Reprints
Stanley and Reginald Pitt are Australian; this is one of their few US credits.
- Script
- Carl Wessler
- Pencils
- Alfredo Alcala
- Inks
- Alfredo Alcala
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Murray Boltinoff (original editor)
- Job Number
- B-1399
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- You think you've heard everything?
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Mildred (host)
- Reprints
- Script
- George Kashdan (credited)
- Pencils
- Rudy Florese (credited)
- Inks
- Rudy Florese (credited)
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Dick Giordano (original editor); Cary Burkett (original associate editor)
- Job Number
- [J-5789]
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- Not a bad brew, Mildred, but I Mordred have cooked up a delicious main course!
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Mordred (host); John Benson [Walter Casper]; Trunche; Hilda Benson; Professor Scott
- Synopsis
- John Benson, wanted for murder, has the warlock Trunche transform him into another person.
- Reprints
- Script
- ?
- Pencils
- Bob Brown
- Inks
- Bob Brown
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Whitney Ellsworth (credited) (original editor)
- Job Number
- N-792
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- They laughed at me because he sought something--someone--who supposedly existed in man's mind alone!
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Cynthia (host)
- Reprints
This reprint is sourced from The Witching Hour (DC, 1969 series) #38 (January 1974) and has a small image of Cynthia added as host on the first page. The introductory words have been incorrectly edited as Cynthia's words, rather than Paul Hastings ('laughed at me' rather than 'laughed at him').
- Script
- Carl Wessler (credited)
- Pencils
- Rudy Nebres (signed)
- Inks
- Rudy Nebres (signed)
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Dave Manak (original editor)
- Job Number
- J-5808
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- Here's a shocker I've drummed up in which greed is a killer…
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Mildred (host)
- Reprints
- Script
- Carl Wessler (credited as C. Wessler)
- Pencils
- Gerry Talaoc (credited as J. Talaoc)
- Inks
- Gerry Talaoc (credited as J. Talaoc)
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Jack C. Harris (original editor)
- Job Number
- J-5821
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- The five terrorists that commandeered the U.S. bound airplane at gunpoint overlooked a cardinal rule of the skies--
- Characters
- Cynthia; Mildred; Mordred (also as host)
- Reprints
- Script
- Carl Wessler (credited)
- Pencils
- Jerry Grandenetti (credited)
- Inks
- Jerry Grandenetti (credited)
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Murray Boltinoff (original editor)
- Job Number
- B-2043
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- He was a beautiful person to Mac and Jeannie Dowling.
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Cynthia (host)
- Reprints
- Script
- Leo Dorfman (credited)
- Pencils
- Alex Niño (credited)
- Inks
- Alex Niño (credited)
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Murray Boltinoff (original editor)
- Job Number
- B-1960
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- How crude can you get?
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Mildred (host)
- Reprints
- Script
- Robert Kanigher (credited as Bob Kanigher)
- Pencils
- Vic Catan (credited as Vicatan)
- Inks
- Vic Catan (credited as Vicatan)
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Dave Manak (original editor)
- Job Number
- J-7574
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- Myth and today's headlines exist side by side in the magical isles of Greece!
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Mordred (host); Rona Douglas; Medusa; Athena; Perseus
- Reprints
The final panel of the original story, which features Mordred promoting the next issue of The Unexpected, has been replaced with a small Murray Comics promotion.
- Script
- ?
- Pencils
- ?
- Inks
- ?
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Whitney Ellsworth (original editor, credited)
- Job Number
- N-788
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- Right now, Harvey Byrd, you are blind as a bat!
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Mildred (host)
- Reprints
This version of the story has Mildred as host and is probably sourced from the reprint in The Witching Hour (DC, 1969 series) #38 (January 1974).
- Script
- Bob Haney (credited)
- Pencils
- Pat Boyette (credited)
- Inks
- Pat Boyette (credited)
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Murray Boltinoff (original editor)
- Job Number
- G-555
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- Oohoohhooo oh ho! Oh, ho! When the moon is gibbous and the owl cries fowl…
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Mordred (host)
- Reprints
- Script
- ?
- Pencils
- George Papp (credited)
- Inks
- George Papp (credited)
- Letters
- Artie Simek
- Editing
- Whitney Ellsworth (original editor)
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- From the yellowed pages of a 13th century diary leapt the words that told the story of a modern magician…
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Cynthia (host)
- Reprints
This printing includes an image of Cynthia as host and is probably sourced from the reprint in The Witching Hour (DC, 1969 series) #38 (January 1974).
- Script
- Carl Wessler (credited)
- Pencils
- Frank Redondo (credited)
- Inks
- June Lofamia (credited)
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Murray Boltinoff (original editor)
- Job Number
- B-798
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- To what extreme will ambition drive a man?
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Mildred (host)
- Reprints
- Script
- Carl Wessler (credited)
- Pencils
- Buddy Gernale (credited)
- Inks
- Alfredo Alcala (signed as Fred P. Alcala)
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Murray Boltinoff (original editor)
- Job Number
- B-1687
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- Hang onto your heart or it'll leap right out of your mouth at this terrible tale of treachery…
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Reprints
- Script
- ?
- Pencils
- Alex Toth
- Inks
- Dick Giordano
- Letters
- ?
- Editing
- Dick Giordano (original editor)
- Job Number
- [G-139]; N-785
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- ...And that's that!
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Characters
- Cynthia; Mildred; Mordred
- Reprints
Based on the job code, this printing is sourced from the reprint in The Witching Hour (DC, 1969 series) #38 (January 1974), which used an updated number. This is the conclusion of framing sequence.
- Script
- Tamsyn O'Flynn (credited)
- Pencils
- Keith Giffen (credited)
- Inks
- Bob Smith (credited)
- Letters
- Pierre Bernard Jr. (credited)
- Editing
- Karen Berger (original editor)
- Job Number
- J-7814
- First Line of Dialogue or Text
- There have been many women in this life…
- Genre
- horror-suspense
- Reprints
This feature is on the inside back cover.